Viravuth Yin 博士是Mount Desert Island Biological Laboratory (MDIBL) 的副教授。科研誠信辦公室 (ORI) 發現 Viravuth Yin 博士在美國公共衛生服務 (PHS) 等基金支持的研究中從事研究不端行為。
Viravuth Yin有意、故意和/或偽造和/或捏造以下三 (3) 篇已發表論文和兩 (2) 篇已提交手稿中的數據,從事研究不端行為。Viravuth Yin重復使用、重新標記和報告磷酸鹽緩沖鹽水 (PBS) 作為亂序反義鎖定核酸 (LNA)的對照;Viravuth Yin通過不做或者是少做實驗,得到相關的實驗結果。Viravuth Yin同意接受2年的監督及撤回已經發表在Development,iScience 等3篇文章的要求。
ORI對于科研誠信的調查案例及結果報告,這也能為中國的相關科研誠信部門等調查相關的案例,提供了借鑒。
Viravuth Yin 博士:基于Mount Desert Island Biological Laboratory (MDIBL) 進行的調查報告和科研誠信辦公室 (ORI) 在其監督審查中進行的額外分析,ORI發現 Viravuth Yin 博士(被調查人),前 MDIBL 副教授,在美國公共衛生服務 (PHS) 等基金支持的研究中從事研究不端行為。
Viravuth Yin既不承認也不否認 ORI 的研究不當行為調查結果。雙方簽訂本協議以完成此事項,無需進一步花費時間、財務或其他資源。
ORI 發現,Viravuth Yin有意、故意和/或偽造和/或捏造以下三 (3) 篇已發表論文和兩 (2) 篇已提交手稿中的數據,從事研究不端行為:
Smith AM, Dykeman CA, King BL, Yin VP. Modulation of TNFα Activity by the microRNA Let-7 Coordinates Heart Regeneration. iScience 2019;15:1-15; doi: 10.1016/j.isci.2019.04.009(以下簡稱“iScience 2019”)
Smith AM, Dykeman CA, King BL, Yin VP. Modulation of TNFα Activity by the microRNA Let-7 Coordinates Heart Regeneration. iScience 2019;17:225-29; doi: 10.1016/j.isci.2019.06.017(以下簡稱“iScience Correction”)
Beauchemin M, Smith A, Yin VP. Dynamic microRNA-101a and Fosab expression controls zebrafish heart regeneration. Development 2015;142:4026-37; doi: 10.1242/dev.126649(以下簡稱“Development 2015”)
Smith AM, Dykeman CA, Yin VP. Modulation of epicardial TNFα Activity by the microRNA Let-7 Coordinates the Zebrafish Heart Regeneration. Manuscript submitted to iScience in 2018(以下簡稱“iScience 2018稿件”)
Smith AM, Dykeman CA, Yin VP. Modulation of epicardial TNFα Activity by the microRNA let-7 coordinates the zebrafish heart regeneration. Manuscript submitted to PNAS in 2018(以下簡稱“PNAS 2018稿件”)
具體而言,Viravuth Yin通過以下方式有意、故意和/或不計后果地偽造和/或捏造數據:
在以下實驗結果中重復使用、重新標記和報告磷酸鹽緩沖鹽水 (PBS) 對照作為亂序反義鎖定核酸 (LNA):
RT-qPCR data representing the knockdown of let7 expression in Figure 2B of PNAS 2018 draft, iScience 2018 draft, and iScience 2019
images of tcf21:Dsred expression in LNA-let-7 treated hearts at 3, 14, and 21 days post -amputation (dpa) showing defects in wound closure in Figure 2C of PNAS 2018 draft, iScience 2018 draft, and iScience 2019
quantification of tcf21:Dsred expression within the resection wound in LNA-let-7 treated hearts in Figure 2D of iScience 2019
images exhibiting proliferating cardiac muscle (CM) in Figure 3A of PNAS 2018 draft, iScience 2018 draft, and iScience 2019
suppression of CM proliferation indices in LNA-let-7 hearts at 3 and 7 dpa in Figure 3B of PNAS 2018 draft, iScience 2018 draft, and iScience 2019
severity of the injured heart phenotype in Figure 3C of PNAS 2018 draft, iScience 2018 draft, and iScience 2019
quantification of the severity of the injury heart phenotype in Figure 3D of iScience 2019
electron microscopy images of remote and injury zones of resected 7-dpa hearts in Figure 4A of PNAS 2018 draft, iScience 2018 draft, iScience 2019, and iScience Correction
images of Tg(gata4:GFP) expression in the primordial heart muscle layer in Figure 4B of PNAS 2018 draft, iScience 2018 draft, iScience 2019, and iScience Correction
quantification of gata4:GFP expression in control and LNA-let-7 treated hearts in Figure 4C of iScience 2019 and iScience Correction
RNA transcripts identifying differentially upregulated TNFα transcripts in Figure 5A of PNAS 2018 draft, iScience 2018 draft, iScience 2019, and their resultant qPCR results, which identified increased TNFα expression in Figure 5C of PNAS 2018 draft, Figure 5B of iScience 2018 draft, iScience 2019, and Table S1 of iScience 2019
CM proliferation analyses results in Figures S4B and S4C of PNAS 2018 draft and iScience 2018 draft, and Figures S5B and S5C of iScience 2019
images representing the function of let-7 in Figure 2C of iScience Correction and reusing and relabeling images from an unrelated experiment, such that let-7 function is not represented in the image
images reporting the function of let-7 in Figure 3A of iScience Correction
images representing differences in the effects of miR-101a depletion on Met2 and PNA expression and the quantification of cardiomyocyte proliferation in uninjured control and Tg(hs:miR-101a-sp) heat exposed hearts (CM proliferation analysis) in Figures 2A, 2B, 2C, and 2D, and results in Figure 2E of Development 2015
muscle, fibrin, and collagen staining images representing increased scar tissue presence in Tg(hs:miR-101a-sp) heat-treated hearts, as compared to wild type hearts in Figures 3A, 3B, 3C, 3D, 3E, and 3F of Development 2015
scarring indices and the size of the injured area in wild type versus Tg(hs:miR-101a-sp) heat-treated hearts in Figures 3G and 3H of Development 2015
differences in (1) the amount of scarring, as represented by AFOG staining in control and Tg (hs:miR-101-a-sp) ventricles from resected and heat-treated hearts in Figures 4B and 4C; (2) the amount of scar tissue in the presence of suppressed miR-101a expression in Tg(hs:miR-101a-sp) hearts, compared to control hearts in Figures 4H and 4I; and (3) the quantification of the scarring indices in control versus Tg(hs:miR-101a-sp) hearts in Figure 4J of Development 2015
differences in (1) the amount of scarring, as represented by comparing AFOG staining in control and Tg(hs:miR-101a-sp) and Tg(hs:miR-133a1-pre) hearts exposed to long term heat therapy in Figures 5A, 5B and 5C, or Tropomyosin staining in Figures 5D, 5E, and 5F; and (2) the quantification of the scarring indices, tropomyosin expression, and injury area in Figures 5G, 5H, and 5I of Development 2015
increased Fosab expression in Tg(hs:miR-101a-sp) ventricles relative to controls in Figures 6A and 6B, RNA in situ hybridization studies in control and regenerating hearts detecting miR-101a expression in Figures 6C, 6D, 6E, and 6E’, and Fosab expression in Figures 6F, 6G, 6H, and 6H’ of Development 2015
images reporting significant differences in Dsred expression, cardiomyocyte proliferation, collagen and fibrin staining, and scar tissue removal in ventricles from zebrafish treated with lna-Let-7, as compared to scrambled control, to support the importance of miR-101a in scar tissue removal/ventricular regeneration in Figures 6H, 6I, 6J, 7C, 7D, and 7E of Development 2015
報告未執行的研究方法和統計數據(以下實驗結果)
PCR data in the graph represented in Figure 2B of PNAS 2018 draft, iScience 2018 draft, and iScience 2019, by representing the data from two (2) remote PCR experiments as being from the same experiment
PCR data in the graph represented in Figure 2B of iScience Correction by reusing and relabeling a graph containing data that were the result of different experimental conditions (exposure to heat shock), to include scrambled control data
control data and statistical differences between control and experimental data represented in PNAS 2018 draft, iScience 2018 draft, iScience 2019, and iScience Correction, by falsely reporting the use of both antisense scrambled and LNA oligonucleotides that were designed and administered to adult animals via intraperitoneal injection at 10ug/g body weight
representing the “n” of one biological replicate or one experiment as being multiple independent samples or experiments in iScience 2019 and iScience Correction
control data and statistical differences between control and experimental data and the reported methods in Development 2015, concluding that miR-101a controls both CM proliferation and scar tissue removal, by falsely reporting the use of LNA oligonucleotides to modulate miR-101 activity in vivo to elucidate its contributions during adult heart regeneration
Viravuth Yin簽訂了自愿和解協議(協議)并自愿同意以下內容:
Viravuth Yin同意自 2021 年 8 月 2 日起對其研究進行為期兩 (2) 年的監督。
Viravuth Yin同意自愿退出 PHS 的任何咨詢職位。
作為本協議的一個條件,Viravuth Yin應該撤回Development 2015 Dec 1;142(23):4026-37;iScience 2019 May 31;15:1-15及iScience 2019 Jul 26;17:225-29等3篇文章。
參考消息:
https://ori.hhs.gov/content/case-summary-yin-viravuth-p-
以往國家自然科學基金主要資助在高校和科研院所任職的教師和研究人員,在校學生無資格申請。從2023年開始,國家自然科學基金委員會在部分高校試點資助優秀本科生和研究生。9月8日,國家自然科學基金首次試點青......
近日,四川成都的網民就“基金申報”年齡問題提出問題,該網民問:“能否創新地考慮對于超齡博士(年齡大于35歲),以畢業年限(如5年內)作為青年基金的申報條件?以便給更多教學或科研工作者從事基礎研究的機會......
近三年前,一位退學碩士研究生以長達123頁的材料實名舉報時任天津大學化工學院教授張裕卿學術不端,如今這一事件又迎來了后續進展。 有人注意到,本月稍早前,原張裕卿團隊于2019年2月8日在期刊......
“科研如登山,我們期待志同道合的登山人加入。”日前,紫金山實驗室發布招聘公告。公告顯示,此次招聘對象為2024屆海內外優秀應屆博士、碩士以及出站博士后。碩士年薪20萬起,博士年薪41萬起,頂尖人才待遇......
近日,2023世界人工智能大會青年優秀論文獎頒獎儀式在上海舉行。西安交大數學與統計學院楊燕博士憑借“一種用于壓縮感知成像的深度學習方法”一文中的相關工作榮獲“2023世界人工智能大會青年優秀論文獎”。......
【解說】首屆中國學位與研究生教育大會暨中國研究生教育長江論壇7月4日在武漢舉行,來自政府主管部門、研究生培養單位和用人單位、院士專家代表、導師和研究生、行業企業代表等參會。【同期】教育部部長懷進鵬學位......
近期,全國多所高校提出“徹底清理學術不端問題論文存量”。科技部辦公廳此前已于4月27日印發“關于開展論文學術不端自查和掛名現象清理工作的通知”。據北京建筑大學科學技術發展研究院網站6月7日消息,按照北......
在研究生階段,學校并不會教你如何管理你的時間,更多的是需要你自己摸索。但學校不教的,恰恰最重要。在讀博的諸多挑戰中,時間管理往往占據首位。根據Nature雜志對全球3200多名研究生的調查,有一半的人......
近日,美國哥倫比亞大學(ColumbiaUniversity)正式公布了2023年度榮譽博士學位授予名單,決定授予包括梅州蕉嶺杰出鄉賢、國際著名數學家、菲爾茲獎首位華人得主丘成桐院士在內的7位知名人士......
近幾年,隨著博士的不斷擴招,關于學歷貶值和博士就業去向的討論,一直很多。近日,華中師范大學圖書館的一則招聘公告引起熱議。招聘顯示,2023年華中師范大學圖書館文獻信息服務崗(非事業編B類崗)招聘3名人......